Skip to main content

Smashing Pumpkins Miss the Mark on New Release


     The Smashing Pumpkins have reunited and dropped a comeback album, except it’s not exactly a full reunion and it’s not quite the comeback we expected to hear. With ¾ of the original Pumpkins back in action (front man Billy Corgan, guitarist James Iha, and drummer Jimmy Chamberlin being the only remnants of the band we all loved in the nineties) 18 years after they delivered their last original work together (2000’s Machina/The Machines of God is a hugely underrated album), their new deliverance, Shiny and Oh So Bright, Vol.1/LP: No Past. No Future. No Sun. is an all too brief affair that has no direction and false promises. Clocking in at just 32 minutes, the eight tracks that make up Shiny and Oh So Bright offer almost nothing to be excited about, and while tracks like “Silvery Sometimes (Ghosts)”, “Solara” and “Marching On” are reminiscent of Pumpkins’ earlier grace and fiery angst and pretty much the album’s only true saviors, it all feels too vacant and lifeless. Album opener “Knights of Malta” may have been an attempt to woo in a younger audience but fails greatly. It sounds like an Imagine Dragons rip-off. Shiny lacks imagination, personality, effort, and love. There is almost nothing to see here from an alternative giant. It’s a big miss. Maybe their time has come and gone. The Pumpkins, or rather Corgan, has been on the decline since reuniting the band back in 2007 with completely new members and this particular OG reunion isn’t helping much, at least not here. Original bassist D’Arcy Wretzky is nowhere to be found. Their reunion tour didn’t sell very well, with a good number of arenas reportedly being only half full. If we examine the work as a whole, Corgan indeed wrote some solid tunes, Chamberlin’s drumming is still some of the best in alternative rock, and Rick Rubin’s crisp and clear production is a true highlight. It just misses the mark for this.
     In the near two decades with all original Pumpkins taking on other projects (Corgan’s short-lived Zwan and shoegazey industrial solo album, Iha’s notable stint in A Perfect Circle, Chamberlin’s jazz fusion album), the terminal vacancy that is Shiny and Oh So Bright feels like an insult to the band’s legacy. Sure, classics cannot be replicated and that’s not the point here, but maybe getting back to their younger selves may have helped their cause. Shiny isn’t a complete throwaway either; simply, and sadly, it will require a few listens for it to grow on you. Corgan, Iha, and Chamberlin work well together. The songs that make up this half-hour album are well composed and standouts in their own right; plainly, it needed more push to convince us that Corgan and crew aren’t stale and are still worthy of our attention.
photo: www.sacurrent.com


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Portrayal of Guilt and Soft Kill Softly Kill You for Portrayal of Guilt

     This past Wednesday, Texas metal ragers Portrayal of Guilt and Portland sad-rockers Soft Kill released an explosive split through Closed Casket Activities, and man, I’m all for it.      To start things off, Portrayal of Guilt’s song “Sacrificial Rite” is a blistering, vicious, brutal two-minute assault, just like in typical hardcore fashion. It’ll have you punching walls and banging your head on tables, and despite its short length, it has a beautiful dynamic that oddly carries you into the next song, Soft Kill’s ethereal “Tin Foil Drop”.      Soft Kill, dubbed by vocalist/guitarist Toby Grave as a “sad-rock” band (moody shit for all the goths out there), further expand on the descriptor with a spacey, shoegaze-y, atmospheric six-minute track that will leave you in tears. It carries bit of synth-pop and Disintegration-era Cure elements to it. It’s a melancholic, moving track that contrasts Portrayal of Guilt’s opener, ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Them Are Us Too Make Amends

      The Bay Area’s euphoric dream pop duo Them Are Us Too began in 2012 with schoolmates Kennedy Ashlyn and Cash Askew playing well balanced eighties inspired synth-pop shoegaze. In 2015, they released their debut album, Remain , a gloomy tour de force to incredible acclaim. They built up a dedicated cult following, and that success hyped the anticipation for the follow-up to their big debut. Tragically in 2016, a warehouse fire claimed Askew’s life at 22 years old, putting the band’s career in uncertainty. However, through the ashes of tragedy arose a new album, Amends , the band’s second and final as TAUT (as fans call them) and it is a beautifully haunting piece of work filled with ethereal elegance and atmospherics.      Amends , as Ashlyn describes, is “a collection of songs that would have been the second Them Are Us Too record, an amendment to our catalog cut short, a final gift to family, friends, and fans.” Amends is a celeb...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Cure: Thirty Years of Disintegration

     Iconic goth-rock band The Cure are having a very big 2019. Not only were they inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame by none other than industrial-goth symbol Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails, their emblematic masterpiece, Disintegration , turned 30 years old and they are celebrating by touring the world and playing the album in its entirety. What a wow!      Disintegration is one of those albums that has grown bigger and better over time since its release. It is the pinnacle of the band’s growth over the previous decade, a milestone in their career, and, most importantly, the record that beautifully captures the band’s creative powers at its peak. It is inarguably THE quintessential goth-rock album of all time ( Pornography , another bleak Cure release, is number two). Characterized by a significant use of synthesizers and keyboards, slow and droning guitar progressions awash with chorus and flange effects (a signature sound for the band),...
Post a Comment
Read more